10 Mystery TV Shows That Kept Us Guessing From Start To Finish

There are many mystery TV shows that will keep viewers guessing until the very end, turning every initial idea and suspicion on its head. The mystery genre has continued to captivate on the small screen by utilizing a serialized format to steadily unpack clues, red herrings, motives, and more over the course of weeks, months or even years, creating an addictive quality that is unavailable in feature films. Unlike detective movies confined to a two-hour run-time, mystery shows like Lost allow characters, relationships, and suspects to marinate while the core investigation simmers, building anticipation for the final reveals.

Very much an interactive experience between creator and viewer, the mystery show provides an invitation into detective work, encouraging the scrutiny of details and situations for anything purposely misleading. To satisfy this innate human urge for discovery, an abundance of numerous nail-biting mystery series spanning from classic whodunits to supernatural investigations keep viewers perpetually guessing with new twists. For those seeking suspenseful stories that stimulate the inner sleuth, there are multiple series to choose from that stimulate the desire to theorize and keep armchair detectives eternally on the edge of their seats.

Related

The Best TV Shows Of All Time, Ranked

The best TV shows of all time will be debated forever, but there are clear contenders. These are the very best TV shows of all time, ranked.

10 The White Lotus (2021-)

Satisfies The Hunger For Mystery, Suspense, And Surprises.

The White Lotus is an unpredictable, twist-filled anthology series that has kept the guesses flowing for two seasons. Created by Mike White, each season follows different guests and employees at the chain of luxury White Lotus resorts, showing how their dysfunctional behaviors and psyches impact one another, often leading to mysterious deaths.

Debuting in 2021 to critical acclaim and high ratings, the black comedy has won Emmys and Golden Globes for its talented cast. It is a hilarious satire with complex characters who defy being simple cartoonish examples of privileged people. Along with the comedy, there is a lot of tension throughout the series as the audience knows someone will die and the possibilities are wide open. Originally a limited series set in Hawaii, the show’s popularity led HBO to order more seasons set in new exotic locations like Sicily and season 3 of The White Lotus in Thailand.

9 Only Murders In The Building (2021-)

An Innovative Murder Mystery Set In An Apartment Building.

Only Murders in the Building is an unpredictable murder mystery series following an unlikely trio of amateur sleuths. The show focuses on three neighbors in New York’s Arconia building who join forces to investigate deaths happening in their residence, uncovering new suspects and twists with each season. It makes for a fun story of this unlikely friendship that emerges.

Debuting in 2021, the Hulu original stands out for its quirky characters, clever writing, and inventive blend of crime-solving and themes of friendship and community. There have been some big-name guest stars on the series, from Meryl Streep to Tina Fey to Paul Rudd, but the show never makes it too easy to reveal who the latest killer is. With its fresh approach to the murder mystery genre, Only Murders in the Building continues to surprise and delight as its characters attempt to crack new cases.

8 Broadchurch (2013-2017)

Stands Out As a Captivating Whodunnit.

Broadchurch follows two detectives, played masterfully by David Tennant and Olivia Colman, investigating the shocking murder of a young boy in a sleepy coastal town where everyone knows one another. Grippingly portrayed, the mystery leaves no possibility unturned, with each suspect somehow more tragic than the last. It is one of the best British murder mysteries with the brooding small-town crime stories that become so popular in the genre.

Broadchurch’s appeal is with its mounting suspense, grief-stricken, yet secretive characters, and the palpable chemistry between Tennant and Colman. While subsequent seasons couldn’t quite match the power of the first, Broadchurch remains one of the most suspenseful and addictive crime dramas due to phenomenal acting and an unpredictably constructed mystery. The combination of quality actors, invigorating stories, and stunning twists make it one of the best mystery shows in recent memory.

7 Cruel Summer (2021-2023)

An Addictive Anthology Murder Mystery Full Of Twists And Interwoven Storylines.

The teen mystery show Cruel Summer follows a group of teenagers, exploring the fallout when one goes missing or dies. Season 1 unfolds between 1993 and 1995, detailing Kate Wallis’ disappearance and Jeanette Turner’s suspicious rise in social status during her absence. Season 2, set from 1999 through 2000, begins with the murder of a teen girl, initiating an investigation that reveals ugly secrets about the victim and her friends.

Lauded for its nuanced teenage characters, creative storytelling across multiple time periods, and exploration of trauma, Cruel Summer excels at fusing elements of thrillers and teen dramas into an unpredictable, gripping mystery. With the young cast of characters, the show is able to touch on some impactful and powerful themes while also keeping the audience guessing with its riveting mystery. So far, each season has featured a major plot twist that is difficult to see coming right up until the moment it happens.

6 Lost (2004-2010)

Kept Viewers Guessing With New Mysteries, While Slowly Unraveling Existing Ones.

When Lost first aired in 2004, it brought an innovative new approach to the mystery drama genre. Lost stranded an ensemble cast of characters on a mysterious island after a plane crash, where they encountered strange phenomena and threats. It becomes clear that this island is not an ordinary place and the mystery increases when the survivors realize that they are not the only ones on the island.

What set the series apart was its heavy focus on developing each character’s backstory through flashbacks and interweaving their past narratives with the strange happenings on the island. Lost ambitiously blended sci-fi, supernatural, and spiritual elements into its story, adding to the mystery and intrigue. Though the ending of Lost was controversial, it redefined what a mystery TV show could be with some of the most iconic twists in television history.

5 Severance (2022)

A Mysterious Sci-fi That Is Full Of Conspiracies.

What appears to be a simple scenario of a man undergoing a corporate “severance” procedure that divides his memories between work and his personal life spirals into an intricate mystery thriller in the series Severance. Beneath its simple exterior, the show creatively tackles the themes of identity, reality, and work-life balance, all viewed through the lens of a mysterious, conspiracy-driven, science-fiction narrative.

When Lumon Industries employee Mark begins noticing contradictions between his severed halves, he’s driven to uncover his employer’s secret intentions. This well-constructed mind-bender cements itself as an original series that leaves one eagerly waiting for the second season to unveil the next layer to its mysteries. There is a surrealness to the world but the story is grounded in the characters as they decide to fight for the freedom that has been denied to them.

4 Dark (2017-2020)

An Unpredictable Mystery That Requires Full Attention.

The German sci-fi thriller Dark masters complex, multi-generational suspense across its three mystery-filled seasons. The central mystery starts in 2019 when children vanish in the German town of Winden, reminiscent of disappearances from past years. What unfolds is a tangled web of conspiracy tying four families to a cave that enables time travel, ultimately exposing the sinister secrets and lies buried within the interconnected past, present and future of the isolated community.

Attentive viewing is necessary in order to understand and solve the philosophical mysteries and interwoven timelines leading to the emotional finale. It is not an easy story to delve into, but there is a rewarding aspect to watching such an ambitious story come together in a satisfying way. With its dense storytelling and exceptional cast, Dark is a truly unique and bold mystery.

3 Manifest (2018-2023)

A Grounded Character Drama Mixed With Supernatural Mysteries.

Manifest hooked viewers with its central mystery across three seasons starting in 2018, originally on NBC before Netflix revived it for a final season. The supernatural drama kicks off when Montego Air Flight 826 lands in New York after a turbulent ride, but surprisingly, five years have inexplicably passed for the world since the flight’s departure. The show is like Lost in that it explores the lives of various people impacted by the same strange flight gone wrong.

It is a brilliant premise that immediately draws viewers in with the desire to learn more about how this happened and what it could mean. While exploring relatable emotional arcs focused on the relationships fractured by the passengers’ disappearance, Manifest intrigues with slowly unfolding clues about the aircraft’s link to larger forces. The show succeeds through a balance of grounded character drama and otherworldly reveals.

2 Yellowjackets (2021-)

A Complex Mystery Across Dual Timelines.

With Lost, Manifest, and now Yellowjackets, it seems getting on a plane sets up a wild mystery in a lot of shows. Considered one of the best shows of 2023, Yellowjackets chronicles a New Jersey girls’ soccer team’s desperate battle for survival during 19 months stranded in the remote wilderness after a horrific plane crash. Alongside the unfolding of their struggle in the past, Yellowjackets also spotlights the present-day lives of the now-adult survivors of the crash, suggesting their months in the forest changed them and harbored mysterious secrets.

Captivating and compelling as it reveals the traumatized teenagers’ frightening descent into violence with hints at supernatural elements, this series intentionally leaves many elements ambiguous in order to keep speculation high about what truly transpired for these girls prior to their rescue. There are also some darkly comedic moments to add more layers to the series.

1 True Detective (2014-)

A Stellar First Season That Was Unpredictable And Riveting.

As an anthology, True Detective reinvents itself each season, but none have quite matched the success of the 2014 first season starring Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson as troubled detectives work at solving murders in Louisiana. The mystery lies in the fragmented timelines that peer into the detectives’ flawed pasts. While the show is much more of a look at these two men, it is also a mystery that unfolds brilliantly, inspire many fan theories.

Gripping portrayals of the partners’ self-destructive tendencies add drama to the narrative, risking the investigation’s path as the sinister killings seem to connect to one detective’s experiences. Half crime drama and half Southern Gothic, the haunting first season remains True Detective’s best, saturating every frame with palpable suspense that leaves one anxiously speculating about the truth until the finale’s shocking reveal.